The AFL has taken steps to address domestic violence by partnering with Our Watch to implement education and training programs in all AFL and AFLW clubs. While this initiative has received widespread support, there are concerns about the league’s inconsistent response to violence against women. In the same month that the AFL made this commitment, there was a proposal to induct former North Melbourne champion Wayne Carey, who has a history of violent behavior, into the Australian Football Hall of Fame as a “legend.” However, the AFL ultimately decided to block this move, citing the need to uphold their stance against violence against women.
There is a pattern in the world of sports where violent men are often given opportunities for redemption and second chances, even after committing egregious acts of violence. This leniency can be attributed to the players’ talent and status within the sports industry, allowing them to continue their careers and receive praise and recognition. However, there comes a point where forgiveness and second chances may no longer be appropriate, especially when the behavior continues or worsens over time. Former Geelong champion Jimmy Bartel has spoken out against giving repeated chances to players like Tarryn Thomas, who has faced disciplinary action for threatening a woman with violence.
Bartel, who has personal experience with domestic violence in his own family, has expressed concern about the culture within the AFL and the message it sends to victims and survivors of domestic violence. He believes that tough decisions and zero tolerance policies are more effective in shifting the culture and preventing further harm. While forgiveness and support can be important, there are cases where the privilege of playing at the AFL level should not extend to those who have repeatedly engaged in violent behavior.
It is crucial to listen to the voices of those who have experienced the trauma of domestic violence and prioritize their safety and well-being. Rather than focusing solely on symbolic gestures or gestures of support, there is a need for meaningful action and accountability within the sports industry to address and prevent violence against women. Bartel’s stance on offering repeated chances to individuals with histories of violence highlights the importance of holding players accountable and setting clear boundaries to protect the integrity of the sport and the safety of its participants.
Ultimately, the issue of domestic violence within the AFL and sports more broadly requires a comprehensive and nuanced approach to address systemic issues and protect vulnerable individuals. While gestures of support and awareness are important, concrete actions and policies need to be implemented to ensure that players are held accountable for their actions and that the safety and well-being of all individuals, particularly women, are prioritized. By listening to the voices of survivors and advocates and advocating for a zero-tolerance approach to violence, the sports industry can work towards creating a safer and more equitable environment for all participants.
