Bachelor Nation has been left searching for answers since Gerry Turner and Theresa Nist announced their split on Good Morning America, citing disagreements over where to live as the main reason for their breakup. Gerry had been living in Indiana while Theresa resided in New Jersey, and they were unable to come to a decision on a location to live together. Hours after the announcement, it was reported that Gerry had filed for divorce in his hometown of Petersburg, Indiana.
Speculation surrounding the cause of their breakup has included Gerry’s past, where he dated multiple women following the death of his first wife and faced accusations of fat-shaming. However, Theresa denied that this was a factor in their split, as Gerry had already discussed the issue with her prior to the report being released. Other theories suggest that their families played a role, as they both have separate children and grandchildren from previous relationships, making it difficult for them to fully integrate their lives.
One of the sources of contention in Gerry and Theresa’s relationship was Theresa’s job, which caused a strain as she continued to work and be away from home. Theresa had initially only planned to be on The Golden Bachelor for two weeks but ended up staying longer, causing challenges in their relationship. Gerry expressed a desire for fun and adventure and struggled with adapting to Theresa’s work schedule, leading to difficulties in their relationship.
Lifestyle differences may have also contributed to the split, with reports suggesting that Theresa was perceived as too “uppity” for Gerry and unwilling to adapt to his lifestyle in Indiana. Sources from Theresa’s inner circle revealed that they had been fighting since after the wedding, indicating that there were longstanding issues that eventually led to their breakup. The pair had differences in opinions on various lifestyle decisions, further complicating their relationship.
A rumored comment from Theresa during a visit to Indiana where she discussed potential development of the land sparked disagreements between the couple. Ben Higgins shared the story on his podcast, suggesting that this was a turning point in their relationship as they realized they did not see the world in the same way. Despite being accused of creating rumors, Ben maintained that the story was based on true sources and indicated that it played a significant role in Gerry and Theresa’s breakup.
Overall, various factors including disagreements over living arrangements, past relationships, job commitments, lifestyle differences, and differing world views contributed to Gerry and Theresa’s breakup. As Bachelor Nation continues to speculate on the reasons behind their split, it is clear that there were a combination of issues that ultimately led to the end of their marriage. Despite their televised wedding and initial excitement as a couple, it is evident that they faced numerous challenges that were insurmountable, leading to their decision to divorce.
