The 2024 NFL draft has just concluded, prompting analysts to provide early grades for each team’s selections. While it typically takes a few seasons to accurately assess the success of a draft class, this exercise allows for some initial evaluations. The methodology used in grading each team takes into consideration trades and other factors that affect their overall performance.
The Chicago Bears top the list with an A+ grade, primarily due to their selection of USC quarterback Caleb Williams and Washington wide receiver Rome Odunze. General Manager Ryan Poles also made impactful moves in previous seasons, such as trading for defensive end Montez Sweat and acquiring pass rusher Austin Booker in the fifth round. The Bears look to have a promising rookie crop that could significantly contribute to their success in the upcoming season.
The Pittsburgh Steelers also received an A+ grade for their strong draft, focusing on upgrading their offensive line to support their new quarterback options. Top selections Troy Fautanu and Zach Frazier, along with other picks, should help bolster their roster and improve their offense under new Offensive Coordinator Arthur Smith. The Steelers made strategic moves to address key areas of need and set themselves up for success in the future.
The Philadelphia Eagles earned an A grade for their draft, highlighted by their selection of defensive back Quinyon Mitchell and versatile defensive back Cooper DeJean. With other promising picks like pass rusher Jalyx Hunt, the Eagles have improved their defense and added depth to key positions. Overall, their draft class looks solid and should contribute positively to their team’s performance.
The Los Angeles Chargers received an A grade for their draft, focusing on acquiring quality players that fit their team’s needs. Head Coach Jim Harbaugh and General Manager Joe Hortiz made selections like offensive tackle Joe Alt and wide receiver Ladd McConkey, who have the potential to start on opening day. The Chargers made smart moves to address key positions and set themselves up for success in the upcoming season.
The New York Giants earned an A grade for their draft, which included selecting wide receiver Malik Nabers in the first round to provide a boost to their offense. General Manager Joe Schoen and Head Coach Brian Daboll made strategic picks to address key areas of need and strengthen their roster. With additions like cornerback Dru Phillips and pass rusher Brian Burns, the Giants have set themselves up for success in the future.
The Washington Commanders received an A- grade for their draft, led by the selection of quarterback Jayden Daniels as a long-sought franchise quarterback. New additions like defensive tackle Johnny Newton and wide receiver Luke McCaffrey should bolster their roster and provide impactful contributions. Despite some areas that still need improvement, the Commanders made significant strides in building a competitive team for the upcoming season.
